PITCAIRN, Allegheny County — The close-knit borough of Pitcairn is in mourning following a tragic and violent night earlier this week, when three teenagers—all under 18—were shot at an apartment. Two of the victims, identified by the Allegheny County Medical Examiner’s Office, were fatally wounded on-site: Isiah McCarthy, 16, of Pitcairn, and Tyrant Sutton, 16, of Clairton. A third teenager was also shot but survived with serious injuries; their identity has not yet been released.
🕯️ What We Know So Far
-
The shooting occurred on Thursday evening inside a modest apartment in Pitcairn.
-
First responders discovered Isiah and Tyrant with gunshot wounds; both were declared deceased at the scene. The third teenager was rushed to a nearby hospital.
-
The Medical Examiner’s Office confirmed the teens’ names, ages, and hometowns.
Local and Law Enforcement Response
-
Pitcairn Police, assisted by the Allegheny County Homicide Unit, have launched a full-scale investigation, interviewing witnesses, residents, and collecting forensic evidence.
-
Police Chief Scott Farally has urged anyone with information to come forward: “We’re following every lead. Our youth and community deserve answers and accountability.”
-
No arrests have been made yet; authorities are examining ballistic evidence and surveillance footage.
Community Reaction
-
Residents describe the area as typically quiet, with a deep sense of shared heritage—Pitcairn was once home to bustling rail yards and housed just over 3,100 people at the 2020 census.
-
Local leaders and school officials from the Gateway School District are rallying to support students and families with counseling and community outreach.
-
Borough Mayor Betsy Stevick released a statement expressing profound sorrow and determination: “This borough is hurting. We must stand united to support our young people and ensure our streets are safe.”
Context & Broader Concern
While this specific incident is still under investigation, it is part of a concerning trend of youth-involved shootings across the region. Earlier this year, another alarming case in nearby Braddock tragically claimed the life of a 16-year-old during a juvenile altercation —highlighting that gun violence involving teenagers is a widespread community threat.
What’s Next
-
Investigation Details
-
Police are analyzing shell casings, surveillance video, and digital evidence.
-
A homicide tip line has been established. Anyone with information is urged to call the Allegheny County Detective Bureau at 412‑323‑7161.
-
-
Support for Families and Youth
-
Gateway School District is offering additional trauma-informed counseling and crisis support services for students and families.
-
Local non-profits and faith groups are organizing vigils and resources for the grieving community.
-
-
Call for Action
-
Borough officials are discussing improved street lighting and surveillance.
-
Community advocacy for gun safety programs is gaining traction, as leaders push for broader legislative measures to prevent underage access to firearms.
-
Looking Ahead
-
Timeline: Detectives are expected to provide updates within the next week.
-
Community Meetings: A town hall with law enforcement and school representatives is anticipated to take place in the coming days.
-
Healing: Memorials for the victims are being planned, and residents are organizing vigils to honor Isiah and Tyrant.
How You Can Help
-
If you saw or heard anything around the scene on Thursday evening (e.g., unusual vehicles, voices, or online posts), please contact authorities.
-
Parents: check in on your teens—listen to their fears and concerns, and consider access to mental health or support services.
-
Community groups: explore safe gathering spaces, mentorship programs, and after-school activities to help steer youth away from violence.
Final Thoughts
Pitcairn is reeling from this sudden loss of two young lives. As police pursue justice and families seek closure, the community now faces the larger test of ensuring safety and support for its youth. In these moments of tragedy, the strength of neighbors coming together may offer the hope of healing—and perhaps, the seeds of enduring change.
➡️ Stay safe, stay informed, and stay connected. You can share tips with the Allegheny County tip line (412‑323‑7161) or submit securely at the police department’s website.
