For three long months, the family of Carl Baptist Jr. held onto a thin thread of hope. That hope was officially cut short this week when investigators confirmed that the human remains found in a wooded patch off Stuart Road belonged to the 34-year-old Starkville man. What started as a missing person case back in September has now turned into a grim murder investigation that has shaken the local community.
The story began on a quiet Thursday afternoon, September 18. Carl was last seen at his home in central Starkville around 3:00 p.m., dressed simply in a white t-shirt and boots. When he didn’t come back, his family and local police launched a public appeal for help, hoping someone had seen the 6-foot-2 man. But as the weeks turned into months, the trail grew cold, leaving behind only questions and a growing sense of dread.
v
The break in the case finally came earlier this month when a joint search team, including the Oktibbeha County Sheriff’s Office and Starkville Police, discovered remains in a rural area. It took several days of forensic work by the Mississippi State University Forensic Recovery Unit and state investigators to confirm what many feared. On Friday, the sheriff’s office broke the news: Carl Baptist Jr. was gone.
Authorities didn’t wait long to point to a suspect. Algernon Young, a 37-year-old Starkville resident, has been arrested and charged with first-degree murder and burglary of a dwelling. He is currently being held in the Oktibbeha County Jail without bond. While the police haven’t shared exactly what led them to Young, the charges suggest a violent encounter that began with a break-in and ended in tragedy.
The investigation has also cast a shadow over another local mystery. Reports indicate that Young may be linked to the disappearance of Mitanette Cooper, a woman who hasn’t been seen since June. While investigators have searched Young’s property—even sifting through a burn pile with forensic teams—no evidence of Cooper has been found yet. However, the connection has local residents wondering if these two tragedies are part of a much larger, darker story.
Right now, the sheriff’s department is staying quiet on the specific details of how Carl died. Capt. Brett Watson mentioned that more charges could be coming as they dig deeper into the evidence. They’ve assured the public that there’s no ongoing danger, but for the neighbors in central Starkville, the arrest of a local man for such a violent crime makes it hard to feel completely at ease.
For Carl’s family, the discovery brings a painful kind of closure. The man they spent months searching for is finally coming home, though not in the way anyone had prayed for. As the legal case against Algernon Young moves forward, the community is left to mourn a life cut short and wait for the full truth to come out in court.
